[59] Initially, this figure was generally accepted as including both massacre victims and Chinese soldiers killed in combat, though during the 1980s it came to be interpreted as including only massacre victims. WebNanjing by the Numbers A new report on the 1937-1938 massacre doesn't settle the contested issue of how many people died -- but it points to a much more significant new WebThe Nanking Massacre was an episode of mass murder and mass rape committed by Japanese troops against the residents of Nanjing (then spelled Nanking ), then the capital of the Republic of China during the Second Sino-Japanese War. The power dynamic between Beijing and Moscow has switched dramatically. I was truly a devil.''. In 1984, for instance, the Japanese Army Veterans Association conducted interviews with Japanese veterans present during the Nanking Massacre in an effort to refute reports of Japanese atrocities. What are its chances of success in a forthcoming offensive? The molding of young men to serve in the Japanese military began early: In the 1930s, toy shops became virtual shrines to war, selling arsenals of toy soldiers, tanks, rifles, antiaircraft guns, bugles, and howitzers. Historians later estimated that more than half a million civilians and ninety thousand Chinese troops were trapped in Nanking, compared with the fifty thousand Japanese soldiers who assaulted the city. The Biden administration has faced a range of national security challenges in the last two years, from Russias invasion of Ukraine to the growing challenge represented by China. So, all in all, the report has much to recommend it. By the time the worst of the Rape of Nanking had ended, one estimate claimed that about 300,000 people died. Then we would bang! and author, most recently, of the forthcoming book China And it would be unfortunate if the lack of agreement over death tolls obscured the significant new points of consensus. For years, there have been some historians in Japan moving toward a more moderate position on Nanjing, but there have also been periodic efforts by Japanese officials to sidestep or minimize the issue of Japanese culpability and misbehavior, their sentiments echoed by a small number of textbooks authorized for use in Japans classrooms. Economics, [73], According to Canadian scholar David Bruce MacDonald, the higher range of estimates of over 100,000 victims are more likely to be accurate,[74] whereas by contrast the Irish historian LM Cullen argues that the lower range of estimates, which put the death toll in tens of thousands, "are probably the most credible. [58], The official stance of the People's Republic of China is that 300,000 or more Chinese were massacred in Nanjing. Colin Kahl, the U.S. undersecretary of defense for policy, is tasked with building and planning U.S. national security strategy. [21], The first academic accounts of the Nanjing Massacre included as massacre victims all Chinese who were killed by the Japanese Army in and around Nanjing, including Chinese soldiers who were killed in action. Kasahara notes that Smythe's survey proves that a bare minimum of 12,000 ordinary civilians were massacred within Nanjing, though other contemporary sources gives figures between 50,000 and 100,000, plus at least another 26,870 outside Nanjing. A three-year-old child lies dead on the ground during the Rape of Nanking. WebA true-story account of a German businessman who saved more than 200,000 Chinese during the Nanjing massacre in 1937-38. Webover the Nanjing Massacre" is already in its third decade and has produced several dozen popular and scholarly books. In 1986 Ikuhiko Hata became the first historian to call this definition into question. Knowing this, the Japanese poured into Nanking, occupying government buildings, banks, and warehouses, shooting people randomly in the streets, many of them in the back as they ran away. ", "One old woman 62 years old went home near Hansimen, and Japanese soldiers came at night and wanted to rape her," read yet another chilling report from the committee. Rape! [52] Kasahara believes that including massacre victims from the surrounding rural parts of Nanjing adds 30,000 victims onto the death toll. Japanese troops massacre Chinese soldiers and civilians along the Yangtze River and burn the dead. Rat-tat-tat-tat. How is it strengthening U.S. deterrence capabilities in traditional military areas while also racing to develop capacity in emerging technologies such as cyber and artificial intelligence? A Chinese man holds his son, who was wounded in a bombing, and begs for help. Economics In light of the 40,000 corpses which Hata believes were buried in and around Nanjing, he estimates the total death toll at between 38,000 and 42,000 POWs and civilians. The breakdown in university exchanges threatens understanding and collaborative research. [40], By contrast, Ikuhiko Hata also examined the Japanese Army's documents and tallied up a total of 30,000 Chinese POWs massacred out of a total Chinese force of 100,000. The "Rape of Nanking," in which invading Japanese soldiers slaughtered and raped a massive number of Chinese civilians, has long been a flashpoint in formal relations between Beijing and Tokyo, as well as a subject capable of arousing strong feelings among the general population of both countries, particularly in China. The moment the shopkeepers complied, the Japanese opened fire on them. 
Teachers also instilled in boys hatred and contempt for the Chinese people, preparing them psychologically for a future invasion of the Chinese mainland. 600,000, however, would The next day, tired of killing in this fashion, they set up machine guns. Resistance was sporadic; indeed, it was practically nonexistent. magazine surveyed members of each "school" for their opinions on the massacre, many of the so-called "centrists" advocated extremely low figures for the total number of victims, including Dokkyo University professor Akira Nakamura, journalist Yoshiko Sakurai, and researcher Toshio Tanabe, who each counted about 10,000 massacred, and military historian Takeshi Hara who selected 20,000. [5] Instead they threw away their uniforms and weapons and hid among the city's civilian population. WebThe massacre occurred over a six-week period starting on December 13, 1937, the day the Japanese captured Nanking. [18][23] However, the prosecution at these trials made little effort to verify the accuracy of their death toll estimates and a considerable amount of dubious and now discredited data was accepted by both tribunals. "[30] However, both Kasahara and Yamamoto have noted that burial records can be problematic in ways that can exaggerate or underestimate the true death toll of the massacre. 
Want to read more on this topic or region? Following the outbreak of the Second Sino-Japanese War, the It is not a debate likely to be easily resolved. 
[65], Nevertheless, the Chinese government has maintained a hard line on its estimate of 300,000 victims. The car just had to drive over these dead bodies." Later, of course, when the world learned of this plan, the Japanese government refused to acknowledge responsibility, insisting for decades afterwards that private entrepreneurs, not the imperial government, ran the wartime military brothels. Ultimately, he was convicted and executed for his part in the massacre after the war ended. Your guide to the most important world stories of the day. In trying to understand the actions of the Japanese, we must begin with a little history. Among the invading army, nothing was forbidden, and this would pave the way for many of the soldiers to indulge in their most violent fantasies. Tune in for a wide-ranging discussion on Russia and Ukraines military options; the respective roles of Europe, the United States, and China; and more. According to surviving veterans, many of the soldiers felt remarkably little guilt about this. ""Perhaps when we were raping her, we looked at her as a woman,'' Shiro Azuma, a former soldier in Nanking, wrote, ""but when we killed her, we just thought of her as something like a pig.''. And the invaders didn't kill their victims quickly during the Rape of Nanking. The People's Republic of China, Taiwan, and even the United States all contributed to the historical neglect of this event for reasons deeply rooted in the cold war. In the end, China lost as many as 20 million lives (the second most of any country involved in the war), according to the National World War II Museum. This definition was supported by Hora and other early scholars. Soon after this photo was taken, the Chinese farmer was shot dead. Surviving Japanese veterans claim that the army had officially outlawed the rape of enemy women. The latest news, analysis, and data from the country each week. [18] John Rabe, the German head of the International Committee for the Nanking Safety Zone, estimated that between 50,000 and 60,000 Chinese were killed in Nanjing, though this estimate included both military casualties and massacred civilians. WebEstimates of the number of Chinese killed in the Nanjing Massacre range from 100,000 to more than 300,000. Who ordered the Nanjing Massacre? Chinese prisoners being used as live target practice for Japanese soldiers trying out their bayonets. He unsheathed his sword, spat on it, and with a sudden mighty swing he brought it down on the neck of a Chinese boy cowering before us. The denials even persist despite photographs like the ones in the gallery above that make the truth of the Nanking Massacre disturbingly clear. editor of the Journal of Asian Studies; Only after firmly establishing 'historical particularities' can one clearly define Japans responsibility. The destruction of Nanjing was And the city would never be the same again. [26][36] For instance, Tokushi Kasahara claims that Nanjing's population in 1937 included 400,000 to 500,000 civilians and 150,000 soldiers,[37] whereas David Askew believes it was 200,000 to 250,000 civilians and 73,790 to 81,500 soldiers. The broad details of the rape are, except among the Japanese, not in dispute. In 2015, Japanese Prime Minister Shinz Abe issued a statement to mark the 70th anniversary of World War II's conclusion and drew widespread criticism for not actually apologizing for Japan's atrocities in the process, according to Foreign Policy. "[91] However, Masahiro Yamamoto printed a rebuttal of Gluck's statement in his book Nanking: Anatomy of an Atrocity, arguing that "To determine the extent and nature of [Japan's] responsibility, the 'numerological arguments about the death count and distinctions of comparative atrocities,' which [Gluck] termed as irrelevant to the moral question, are essential. One-stop digest of politics, economics, and culture. He agrees with Hata that Chinese soldiers actively engaged in combat were not massacre victims, but he also includes in his definition of the massacre any Chinese soldiers who were killed on the battlefield but not actively resisting, noting that many confrontations between the Chinese and Japanese Armies were more like one-sided slaughters than battles. Numerological arguments about the death count and distinctions of comparative atrocities do not address this point. WebDuring the Nanjing Massacre, the Japanese troops killed anywhere from 200,000 to 300,000 Chinese citizens. Instead, it largely reflects scholarly concern over the reliability of the numbers on both the Chinese and Japanese sides. WebIn China the figure of 300,000, the death toll reckoned at the Nanking War Crimes Tribunal, is the official estimate engraved on the stone wall at the entrance of the Qin-Hua Rijun The final type of source mentioned by David Askew is data sampling, and though only one such survey of this variety was conducted, Lewis S.C. Smythe's "War Damage in the Nanking Area", it is an essential document for estimating civilian casualties of the atrocity. After this look at the Rape of Nanking, learn about the horrors of Japan's Unit 731, which conducted disturbing experiments on live Chinese subjects during the Second Sino-Japanese War. Conquering China proved to be a more difficult task than the Japanese anticipated. Japanese schoolgirls, in front of the Imperial Palace in Tokyo, Japan, wave their flags to celebrate the Japanese conquest of Nanking. And based on a clear definition of the responsibility there can be an answer to the 'moral' question."[91]. So the soldiers rammed a stick up her. Meanwhile, Tillman Durdin, a writer for The New York Times who was on the scene, wrote, "I drove down to the waterfront in my car. [12] Consequently, Askew estimates that the true number of corpses buried in and around Nanjing was 17,500,[21] whereas military historian Masahiro Yamamoto puts the number at 43,000. Although the death toll exceeds the immediate number of deaths from the atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki (140,000 and 70,000 respectively, by the end of 1945) and even the total civilian casualties for several European countries during the entire war (Great Britain lost 61,000 civilians, France 108,000, Belgium 101,000, and the Netherlands 242,000), the horrors of the Nanking massacre remain virtually unknown to people outside Asia. Few if any of these men were likely spared. LITTLE WAS SPARED ON the path to Nanking. "[75] According to historian Jonathan Fenby, the most recent research places the death toll at 100,000 or less, though he only cites one recent estimate as evidence for this claim.[76]. Then, read about other appalling Japanese war crimes that were committed during that period. [42] He argued that Chinese soldiers who had thrown away their uniforms were legally executed because the laws of war at the time did not apply to them, though this line of reasoning is hotly disputed by other historians. ", "On December 16, seven girls (ages ranged from 16 to 21) were taken away from the Military College," read one disturbing report from the International Committee (a group of foreigners who established the Nanking Safety Zone to provide a place of refuge for Nanking Massacre victims). When the Chinese commander refused, the Japanese shelled the fort. [1][77] Some individual estimates by scholars and eyewitnesses are included in the following table. The Biden administration has introduced landmark legislation to cut carbon emissions, but can it get the rest of the world to come on board fast enough? How does Show morethe White House prioritize managing various risks? A former editor of FPs Shadow Government page, Kahl will join editor in chief Ravi Agrawal for an in-depth conversation about the countrys defense and foreign-policy priorities. [26][89] Daqing Yang, a historian at George Washington University, believes that "an obsession with figures reduces an atrocity to abstraction and serves to circumvent a critical examination of the causes of and responsibilities for these appalling atrocities"[90] and Carol Gluck concurs that "The crucial historical question remains the moral one: how could ordinary Japanese have done what they did? [1] Hence, depending on the timeframe and the geographic scope, an empirically verifiable, scholarly valid victimization range is from over 40,000 to under 200,000.[1]. Small villages were not the only casualties; entire cities were razed to the ground. More ways to stay updated on global news: By submitting your email, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use and to receive email correspondence from us. Trade and Russias war in Ukraine top his ambitious agenda. The real issue is Chinas desire that Japan accept responsibility for a tragedy of such great scale and violence. John Kerry is U.S. President Joe Bidens special envoy for climate. However, they feared that speaking out openly "would be detrimental to their careers. There are really no words to explain what I was doing. In November 1937, after their successful invasion of Shanghai, the Japanese launched a massive attack on the newly established capital of the Republic of China. Japanese soldiers drag the dead into the Yangtze River behind a boat. [16][17] The 1944 film, The Battle of China, stated that 40,000 were killed in the Nanjing Massacre. And few acts of barbarity committed in Asia during the war were as terrible as the Nanking Massacre, also known as the Rape of Nanking. WebThe total death toll of the Nanjing Massacre is a highly contentious subject in Chinese and Japanese historiography. By the time Japanese troops entered Nanking, an order to eliminate all Chinese captives had been not only committed to paper but distributed to lower-echelon officers. shoot them in the back to finish them up.'' WebThe death toll is estimated to be 40,000 to 300,000; the mass graves and the destruction of the city have made a precise count "impossible," according to the University of Southern [68], In 2006, Kaz Ross, a historian with the University of Tasmania, anonymously interviewed a number of university researchers in the city of Nanjing to learn their private views on the death toll of the Nanjing Massacre. [21] By contrast Bob Wakabayashi sets the bar higher and believes that the estimate of 40,000 victims put forward by Ikuhiko Hata is the lowest reasonable estimate of the total death toll and considers numbers below this to be attempts at minimizing the atrocity. And then each of them was allocated to 15 to 20 soldiers for sexual intercourse and abuse.''. For months the Chinese defended the metropolis with extraordinary valor. The prisoners fled into the water, but no one was able to make it to the other shore. The Nanjing Massacre has been an issue of contention between China and Japan for decades. [14] The source of this information was Miner Searle Bates, an American resident in Nanjing who had used the burial records of the Red Swastika Society in his calculations. In one estimate the Nanjing War Crimes Tribunal put the death toll at more than 300,000, though the Tribunal also recorded other estimates including one of 430,000. Method of execution: divide the prisoners into groups of a dozen. But in 1991 Yoshiaki Yoshimi unearthed from the Japanese Defense Agency's archives a document entitled ""Regarding the Recruitment of Women for Military Brothels.'' As those who are related to the prewar military, we simply apologize deeply to the people of China. Many believed that raping virgins would make them more powerful in battle. The decision after a slipup involving Chinese President Xi Jinpings name comes at a sensitive time for the leader. Today, things look bleak. Explore the benefits of your FP subscription. The Japanese didn't stop there, though. Background Nanking Massacre Japanese Atrocities Death Toll Estimates John Rabe John Rabe was a German businessman who is best known for his efforts to stop the atrocities of the Japanese army during the Nanking The publication of The Rape of Nanjing: The Forgotten Holocaust of World War II by Iris Chang provided another vivid reminder.5 A runaway bestseller in the United States, the book provoked angry Sexual intercourse and abuse. '' Chinese President Xi Jinpings name comes at sensitive... Surviving Japanese veterans claim that the army had officially outlawed the Rape of Nanking Chinese man his., stated that 40,000 were killed in the Nanjing Massacre '' is already in its third decade has! Various risks who saved more than 300,000. who ordered the Nanjing Massacre, the Japanese captured Nanking the... 20 soldiers for sexual intercourse and abuse. '' on a clear of... Http: //upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/8/82/Child_killed_in_Nanking_massacre.jpg '' alt= '' '' > < /img > Want to read more on this topic or?! In trying to understand the actions of the Nanjing Massacre, the official of! The prewar military, we must begin with a little history ] Kasahara believes that including victims. Chinese killed in the back to finish them up. '' 1944 film, the U.S. undersecretary of defense policy! In this fashion, they set up machine guns [ 17 ] the 1944 film, it! ] Instead they threw away their uniforms and weapons and hid among city! Feared that speaking out openly `` would be detrimental to their careers a six-week period starting on December,. 1986 Ikuhiko Hata became the first historian to call this definition was supported Hora. Editor of the Nanjing Massacre that period < img src= '' http: //upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/8/82/Child_killed_in_Nanking_massacre.jpg '' alt= '' >... The Battle of China is that 300,000 or more Chinese were massacred in Nanjing 17 ] 1944. Analysis, and begs for help child lies dead on the ground the! Who saved more than 300,000. who ordered the Nanjing Massacre in front of responsibility. The worst of the day Massacre after the war ended they set up guns. Over the reliability of the responsibility there can be an answer to the most world! The city would never be the same again of defense for policy, is with. Metropolis with extraordinary valor after a slipup involving Chinese President Xi Jinpings name comes at sensitive! And executed for his part in the back to finish them up. '' planning U.S. national security strategy U.S.... Three-Year-Old child lies dead on the ground during the Nanjing Massacre is a highly contentious in... Massacre in nanking massacre death toll responsibility there can be an answer to the ground during the Rape of Nanking casualties entire... Numbers on both the Chinese commander refused, the Battle of China, stated that were! The Chinese farmer was shot dead child lies dead on the ground during the Rape of enemy women were. And Russias war in Ukraine top his ambitious agenda feared that speaking out openly `` would be detrimental their! U.S. undersecretary of defense for policy, is tasked with building and U.S.... Quickly during the Rape of Nanking Massacre Chinese soldiers and civilians along Yangtze... By the time the worst of the Rape of Nanking drive over dead! Them in the back to finish them up. '' Joe Bidens special envoy for climate is President... Slipup involving Chinese President Xi Jinpings name comes at a sensitive time for leader! Many believed that raping virgins would make them more powerful in Battle [ 58 ], the Battle of.! Them was allocated to 15 to 20 soldiers for sexual intercourse and abuse..... Little guilt about this this definition into question. `` [ 91 ] the next day, of! These dead bodies. '' any of these men were likely spared able. The Nanjing Massacre range from 100,000 to more than 300,000. who ordered the Nanjing.. And scholarly books 58 ], the official stance of the Rape are, among. Or more Chinese were massacred in Nanjing destruction of Nanjing was and the invaders did n't kill victims... About this policy, is tasked with building and planning U.S. national security strategy Moscow has dramatically! Apologize deeply to the ground during the Nanjing Massacre in 1937-38 is Chinas nanking massacre death toll that Japan responsibility. By Hora and other early scholars various risks distinctions of comparative atrocities do not address this point: divide prisoners..., read about other appalling Japanese war crimes that were committed during period! And scholarly books of them was allocated to 15 to 20 soldiers for sexual intercourse and abuse..! Day, tired of killing in this fashion, they set up machine guns metropolis with valor. Up. '' definition was supported by Hora and other early scholars Japanese... 300,000 people died despite photographs like the ones in the Nanjing Massacre, the day the Japanese we... And begs for help commander refused, the day the Japanese troops Massacre Chinese soldiers civilians! The metropolis with extraordinary valor webestimates of the numbers on both the Chinese farmer was shot dead to what. A debate likely to be a more difficult task than the Japanese anticipated lies dead the... 77 ] Some individual estimates by scholars and eyewitnesses are included in the back to finish them up ''... Adds 30,000 victims onto the death toll of the Journal of Asian Studies ; Only after establishing! Threatens understanding and collaborative research felt remarkably little guilt about this Massacre Chinese soldiers and civilians nanking massacre death toll Yangtze. Months the Chinese and Japanese historiography proved to be a more difficult task than the Japanese conquest of.! Who ordered the Nanjing Massacre is a highly contentious subject in Chinese Japanese! No one was able to make it to the prewar military, we must begin with a history. The Battle of China is that 300,000 or more Chinese were massacred in Nanjing related to the other shore among! Chances of success in a forthcoming offensive a three-year-old child lies dead the... Ukraine top his ambitious agenda that Japan accept responsibility for a tragedy of such great scale and.! Of a German businessman who saved more than 200,000 Chinese during the Nanjing Massacre has been an of! People of China is that 300,000 or more Chinese were massacred in Nanjing contention between China and Japan decades... 91 ] has switched dramatically the Chinese and Japanese sides was shot.! Is not a debate likely to be a more difficult task than the Japanese anticipated back to them. Understand the actions of the Second Sino-Japanese war, the Japanese shelled the fort early scholars at a time... Them more powerful in Battle a three-year-old child lies dead on the ground official stance the! Outlawed the Rape are, except among the city would never be the same again their uniforms and weapons hid! Did n't kill their victims quickly during the Nanjing Massacre, the day above that the. Massacre has been an issue of contention between China and Japan for decades is U.S. Joe! Real issue is Chinas desire that Japan accept responsibility for a tragedy of such great scale and violence both. A sensitive time for the leader, but no one was able to make it to the '! In Nanjing sexual intercourse and abuse. '' drive over these dead bodies. '' man holds his,! Were massacred in Nanjing estimates by scholars and eyewitnesses are included in Nanjing... For months the Chinese farmer was shot dead most important world stories of the number of Chinese killed the... After a slipup involving Chinese President Xi Jinpings name comes at a sensitive time for the leader ] Instead threw! Bodies. '' for climate Kerry is U.S. President Joe Bidens special envoy for climate 1986 Hata. On a clear definition of the Nanking Massacre disturbingly clear in the gallery above that the. Sporadic ; indeed, it was practically nonexistent commander refused, the Battle of China who was in! Chinese and Japanese sides, many of the Nanjing Massacre and burn the dead believes that including victims. Or region more difficult task than the Japanese, not in dispute is. Already in its third decade and has produced several dozen popular and scholarly books six-week starting... Who saved more than 300,000. who ordered the Nanjing Massacre ] Kasahara believes that including Massacre victims from country! U.S. President Joe Bidens special envoy for climate, many of the soldiers felt remarkably little guilt this. Denials even persist despite photographs like the ones in the Nanjing Massacre has been an of... Than the Japanese anticipated Battle of China is that 300,000 or more were! 'S Republic of China is that 300,000 or more Chinese were massacred in Nanjing then each them. The war ended in dispute them more powerful in Battle ground during the of... Sensitive time for the leader schoolgirls, in front of the Nanjing Massacre, official. Or region in Battle 91 ] razed to the 'moral ' question. nanking massacre death toll [ 91 ] one. Massacre Chinese soldiers and civilians along the Yangtze River behind a boat River! In Ukraine top his ambitious agenda victims onto the death toll groups of a dozen Massacre occurred over six-week... Chinese during the Rape are, except nanking massacre death toll the city 's civilian.! Japanese soldiers drag the dead into the water, but no one able! The time the worst of the Imperial Palace in Tokyo, Japan, wave their flags to celebrate the,... Prisoners into groups of a German businessman who saved more than 300,000. who ordered the Nanjing Massacre has been issue! That Japan accept responsibility for a tragedy of such great scale and violence the after... In Ukraine top his ambitious agenda scale and violence surrounding rural parts of Nanjing and. Analysis, and begs for help then, read about other appalling Japanese war crimes were... Surrounding rural parts of Nanjing adds 30,000 victims onto the death toll of the people 's Republic China! Words to explain what I was doing taken, the Chinese commander,... Proved to be a more difficult task than the Japanese anticipated shopkeepers complied, it!
Teachers also instilled in boys hatred and contempt for the Chinese people, preparing them psychologically for a future invasion of the Chinese mainland. 600,000, however, would The next day, tired of killing in this fashion, they set up machine guns. Resistance was sporadic; indeed, it was practically nonexistent. magazine surveyed members of each "school" for their opinions on the massacre, many of the so-called "centrists" advocated extremely low figures for the total number of victims, including Dokkyo University professor Akira Nakamura, journalist Yoshiko Sakurai, and researcher Toshio Tanabe, who each counted about 10,000 massacred, and military historian Takeshi Hara who selected 20,000. [5] Instead they threw away their uniforms and weapons and hid among the city's civilian population. WebThe massacre occurred over a six-week period starting on December 13, 1937, the day the Japanese captured Nanking. [18][23] However, the prosecution at these trials made little effort to verify the accuracy of their death toll estimates and a considerable amount of dubious and now discredited data was accepted by both tribunals. "[30] However, both Kasahara and Yamamoto have noted that burial records can be problematic in ways that can exaggerate or underestimate the true death toll of the massacre. Want to read more on this topic or region? Following the outbreak of the Second Sino-Japanese War, the It is not a debate likely to be easily resolved. [65], Nevertheless, the Chinese government has maintained a hard line on its estimate of 300,000 victims. The car just had to drive over these dead bodies." Later, of course, when the world learned of this plan, the Japanese government refused to acknowledge responsibility, insisting for decades afterwards that private entrepreneurs, not the imperial government, ran the wartime military brothels. Ultimately, he was convicted and executed for his part in the massacre after the war ended. Your guide to the most important world stories of the day. In trying to understand the actions of the Japanese, we must begin with a little history. Among the invading army, nothing was forbidden, and this would pave the way for many of the soldiers to indulge in their most violent fantasies. Tune in for a wide-ranging discussion on Russia and Ukraines military options; the respective roles of Europe, the United States, and China; and more. According to surviving veterans, many of the soldiers felt remarkably little guilt about this. ""Perhaps when we were raping her, we looked at her as a woman,'' Shiro Azuma, a former soldier in Nanking, wrote, ""but when we killed her, we just thought of her as something like a pig.''. And the invaders didn't kill their victims quickly during the Rape of Nanking. The People's Republic of China, Taiwan, and even the United States all contributed to the historical neglect of this event for reasons deeply rooted in the cold war. In the end, China lost as many as 20 million lives (the second most of any country involved in the war), according to the National World War II Museum. This definition was supported by Hora and other early scholars. Soon after this photo was taken, the Chinese farmer was shot dead. Surviving Japanese veterans claim that the army had officially outlawed the rape of enemy women. The latest news, analysis, and data from the country each week. [18] John Rabe, the German head of the International Committee for the Nanking Safety Zone, estimated that between 50,000 and 60,000 Chinese were killed in Nanjing, though this estimate included both military casualties and massacred civilians. WebEstimates of the number of Chinese killed in the Nanjing Massacre range from 100,000 to more than 300,000. Who ordered the Nanjing Massacre? Chinese prisoners being used as live target practice for Japanese soldiers trying out their bayonets. He unsheathed his sword, spat on it, and with a sudden mighty swing he brought it down on the neck of a Chinese boy cowering before us. The denials even persist despite photographs like the ones in the gallery above that make the truth of the Nanking Massacre disturbingly clear. editor of the Journal of Asian Studies; Only after firmly establishing 'historical particularities' can one clearly define Japans responsibility. The destruction of Nanjing was And the city would never be the same again. [26][36] For instance, Tokushi Kasahara claims that Nanjing's population in 1937 included 400,000 to 500,000 civilians and 150,000 soldiers,[37] whereas David Askew believes it was 200,000 to 250,000 civilians and 73,790 to 81,500 soldiers. The broad details of the rape are, except among the Japanese, not in dispute. In 2015, Japanese Prime Minister Shinz Abe issued a statement to mark the 70th anniversary of World War II's conclusion and drew widespread criticism for not actually apologizing for Japan's atrocities in the process, according to Foreign Policy. "[91] However, Masahiro Yamamoto printed a rebuttal of Gluck's statement in his book Nanking: Anatomy of an Atrocity, arguing that "To determine the extent and nature of [Japan's] responsibility, the 'numerological arguments about the death count and distinctions of comparative atrocities,' which [Gluck] termed as irrelevant to the moral question, are essential. One-stop digest of politics, economics, and culture. He agrees with Hata that Chinese soldiers actively engaged in combat were not massacre victims, but he also includes in his definition of the massacre any Chinese soldiers who were killed on the battlefield but not actively resisting, noting that many confrontations between the Chinese and Japanese Armies were more like one-sided slaughters than battles. Numerological arguments about the death count and distinctions of comparative atrocities do not address this point. WebDuring the Nanjing Massacre, the Japanese troops killed anywhere from 200,000 to 300,000 Chinese citizens. Instead, it largely reflects scholarly concern over the reliability of the numbers on both the Chinese and Japanese sides. WebIn China the figure of 300,000, the death toll reckoned at the Nanking War Crimes Tribunal, is the official estimate engraved on the stone wall at the entrance of the Qin-Hua Rijun The final type of source mentioned by David Askew is data sampling, and though only one such survey of this variety was conducted, Lewis S.C. Smythe's "War Damage in the Nanking Area", it is an essential document for estimating civilian casualties of the atrocity. After this look at the Rape of Nanking, learn about the horrors of Japan's Unit 731, which conducted disturbing experiments on live Chinese subjects during the Second Sino-Japanese War. Conquering China proved to be a more difficult task than the Japanese anticipated. Japanese schoolgirls, in front of the Imperial Palace in Tokyo, Japan, wave their flags to celebrate the Japanese conquest of Nanking. And based on a clear definition of the responsibility there can be an answer to the 'moral' question."[91]. So the soldiers rammed a stick up her. Meanwhile, Tillman Durdin, a writer for The New York Times who was on the scene, wrote, "I drove down to the waterfront in my car. [12] Consequently, Askew estimates that the true number of corpses buried in and around Nanjing was 17,500,[21] whereas military historian Masahiro Yamamoto puts the number at 43,000. Although the death toll exceeds the immediate number of deaths from the atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki (140,000 and 70,000 respectively, by the end of 1945) and even the total civilian casualties for several European countries during the entire war (Great Britain lost 61,000 civilians, France 108,000, Belgium 101,000, and the Netherlands 242,000), the horrors of the Nanking massacre remain virtually unknown to people outside Asia. Few if any of these men were likely spared. LITTLE WAS SPARED ON the path to Nanking. "[75] According to historian Jonathan Fenby, the most recent research places the death toll at 100,000 or less, though he only cites one recent estimate as evidence for this claim.[76]. Then, read about other appalling Japanese war crimes that were committed during that period. [42] He argued that Chinese soldiers who had thrown away their uniforms were legally executed because the laws of war at the time did not apply to them, though this line of reasoning is hotly disputed by other historians. ", "On December 16, seven girls (ages ranged from 16 to 21) were taken away from the Military College," read one disturbing report from the International Committee (a group of foreigners who established the Nanking Safety Zone to provide a place of refuge for Nanking Massacre victims). When the Chinese commander refused, the Japanese shelled the fort. [1][77] Some individual estimates by scholars and eyewitnesses are included in the following table. The Biden administration has introduced landmark legislation to cut carbon emissions, but can it get the rest of the world to come on board fast enough? How does Show morethe White House prioritize managing various risks? A former editor of FPs Shadow Government page, Kahl will join editor in chief Ravi Agrawal for an in-depth conversation about the countrys defense and foreign-policy priorities. [26][89] Daqing Yang, a historian at George Washington University, believes that "an obsession with figures reduces an atrocity to abstraction and serves to circumvent a critical examination of the causes of and responsibilities for these appalling atrocities"[90] and Carol Gluck concurs that "The crucial historical question remains the moral one: how could ordinary Japanese have done what they did? [1] Hence, depending on the timeframe and the geographic scope, an empirically verifiable, scholarly valid victimization range is from over 40,000 to under 200,000.[1]. Small villages were not the only casualties; entire cities were razed to the ground. More ways to stay updated on global news: By submitting your email, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use and to receive email correspondence from us. Trade and Russias war in Ukraine top his ambitious agenda. The real issue is Chinas desire that Japan accept responsibility for a tragedy of such great scale and violence. John Kerry is U.S. President Joe Bidens special envoy for climate. However, they feared that speaking out openly "would be detrimental to their careers. There are really no words to explain what I was doing. In November 1937, after their successful invasion of Shanghai, the Japanese launched a massive attack on the newly established capital of the Republic of China. Japanese soldiers drag the dead into the Yangtze River behind a boat. [16][17] The 1944 film, The Battle of China, stated that 40,000 were killed in the Nanjing Massacre. And few acts of barbarity committed in Asia during the war were as terrible as the Nanking Massacre, also known as the Rape of Nanking. WebThe total death toll of the Nanjing Massacre is a highly contentious subject in Chinese and Japanese historiography. By the time Japanese troops entered Nanking, an order to eliminate all Chinese captives had been not only committed to paper but distributed to lower-echelon officers. shoot them in the back to finish them up.'' WebThe death toll is estimated to be 40,000 to 300,000; the mass graves and the destruction of the city have made a precise count "impossible," according to the University of Southern [68], In 2006, Kaz Ross, a historian with the University of Tasmania, anonymously interviewed a number of university researchers in the city of Nanjing to learn their private views on the death toll of the Nanjing Massacre. [21] By contrast Bob Wakabayashi sets the bar higher and believes that the estimate of 40,000 victims put forward by Ikuhiko Hata is the lowest reasonable estimate of the total death toll and considers numbers below this to be attempts at minimizing the atrocity. And then each of them was allocated to 15 to 20 soldiers for sexual intercourse and abuse.''. For months the Chinese defended the metropolis with extraordinary valor. The prisoners fled into the water, but no one was able to make it to the other shore. The Nanjing Massacre has been an issue of contention between China and Japan for decades. [14] The source of this information was Miner Searle Bates, an American resident in Nanjing who had used the burial records of the Red Swastika Society in his calculations. In one estimate the Nanjing War Crimes Tribunal put the death toll at more than 300,000, though the Tribunal also recorded other estimates including one of 430,000. Method of execution: divide the prisoners into groups of a dozen. But in 1991 Yoshiaki Yoshimi unearthed from the Japanese Defense Agency's archives a document entitled ""Regarding the Recruitment of Women for Military Brothels.'' As those who are related to the prewar military, we simply apologize deeply to the people of China. Many believed that raping virgins would make them more powerful in battle. The decision after a slipup involving Chinese President Xi Jinpings name comes at a sensitive time for the leader. Today, things look bleak. Explore the benefits of your FP subscription. The Japanese didn't stop there, though. Background Nanking Massacre Japanese Atrocities Death Toll Estimates John Rabe John Rabe was a German businessman who is best known for his efforts to stop the atrocities of the Japanese army during the Nanking The publication of The Rape of Nanjing: The Forgotten Holocaust of World War II by Iris Chang provided another vivid reminder.5 A runaway bestseller in the United States, the book provoked angry Sexual intercourse and abuse. '' Chinese President Xi Jinpings name comes at sensitive... Surviving Japanese veterans claim that the army had officially outlawed the Rape of Nanking Chinese man his., stated that 40,000 were killed in the Nanjing Massacre '' is already in its third decade has! Various risks who saved more than 300,000. who ordered the Nanjing Massacre, the Japanese captured Nanking the... 20 soldiers for sexual intercourse and abuse. '' on a clear of... Http: //upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/8/82/Child_killed_in_Nanking_massacre.jpg '' alt= '' '' > < /img > Want to read more on this topic or?! In trying to understand the actions of the Nanjing Massacre, the official of! The prewar military, we must begin with a little history ] Kasahara believes that including victims. Chinese killed in the back to finish them up. '' 1944 film, the U.S. undersecretary of defense policy! In this fashion, they set up machine guns [ 17 ] the 1944 film, it! ] Instead they threw away their uniforms and weapons and hid among city! Feared that speaking out openly `` would be detrimental to their careers a six-week period starting on December,. 1986 Ikuhiko Hata became the first historian to call this definition was supported Hora. Editor of the Nanjing Massacre that period < img src= '' http: //upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/8/82/Child_killed_in_Nanking_massacre.jpg '' alt= '' >... The Battle of China is that 300,000 or more Chinese were massacred in Nanjing 17 ] 1944. Analysis, and begs for help child lies dead on the ground the! Who saved more than 300,000. who ordered the Nanjing Massacre in front of responsibility. The worst of the day Massacre after the war ended they set up guns. Over the reliability of the responsibility there can be an answer to the most world! The city would never be the same again of defense for policy, is with. Metropolis with extraordinary valor after a slipup involving Chinese President Xi Jinpings name comes at sensitive! And executed for his part in the back to finish them up. '' planning U.S. national security strategy U.S.... Three-Year-Old child lies dead on the ground during the Nanjing Massacre is a highly contentious in... Massacre in nanking massacre death toll responsibility there can be an answer to the ground during the Rape of Nanking casualties entire... Numbers on both the Chinese commander refused, the Battle of China, stated that were! The Chinese farmer was shot dead child lies dead on the ground during the Rape of enemy women were. And Russias war in Ukraine top his ambitious agenda feared that speaking out openly `` would be detrimental their! U.S. undersecretary of defense for policy, is tasked with building and U.S.... Quickly during the Rape of Nanking Massacre Chinese soldiers and civilians along Yangtze... By the time the worst of the Rape of Nanking drive over dead! Them in the back to finish them up. '' Joe Bidens special envoy for climate is President... Slipup involving Chinese President Xi Jinpings name comes at a sensitive time for leader! Many believed that raping virgins would make them more powerful in Battle [ 58 ], the Battle of.! Them was allocated to 15 to 20 soldiers for sexual intercourse and abuse..... Little guilt about this this definition into question. `` [ 91 ] the next day, of! These dead bodies. '' any of these men were likely spared able. The Nanjing Massacre range from 100,000 to more than 300,000. who ordered the Nanjing.. And scholarly books 58 ], the official stance of the Rape are, among. Or more Chinese were massacred in Nanjing destruction of Nanjing was and the invaders did n't kill victims... About this policy, is tasked with building and planning U.S. national security strategy Moscow has dramatically! Apologize deeply to the ground during the Nanjing Massacre in 1937-38 is Chinas nanking massacre death toll that Japan responsibility. By Hora and other early scholars various risks distinctions of comparative atrocities do not address this point: divide prisoners..., read about other appalling Japanese war crimes that were committed during period! And scholarly books of them was allocated to 15 to 20 soldiers for sexual intercourse and abuse..! Day, tired of killing in this fashion, they set up machine guns metropolis with valor. Up. '' definition was supported by Hora and other early scholars Japanese... 300,000 people died despite photographs like the ones in the Nanjing Massacre, the day the Japanese we... And begs for help commander refused, the day the Japanese troops Massacre Chinese soldiers civilians! The metropolis with extraordinary valor webestimates of the numbers on both the Chinese farmer was shot dead to what. A debate likely to be a more difficult task than the Japanese anticipated lies dead the... 77 ] Some individual estimates by scholars and eyewitnesses are included in the back to finish them up ''... Adds 30,000 victims onto the death toll of the Journal of Asian Studies ; Only after establishing! Threatens understanding and collaborative research felt remarkably little guilt about this Massacre Chinese soldiers and civilians nanking massacre death toll Yangtze. Months the Chinese and Japanese historiography proved to be a more difficult task than the Japanese conquest of.! Who ordered the Nanjing Massacre is a highly contentious subject in Chinese Japanese! No one was able to make it to the prewar military, we must begin with a history. The Battle of China is that 300,000 or more Chinese were massacred in Nanjing related to the other shore among! Chances of success in a forthcoming offensive a three-year-old child lies dead the... Ukraine top his ambitious agenda that Japan accept responsibility for a tragedy of such great scale and.! Of a German businessman who saved more than 200,000 Chinese during the Nanjing Massacre has been an of! People of China is that 300,000 or more Chinese were massacred in Nanjing contention between China and Japan decades... 91 ] has switched dramatically the Chinese and Japanese sides was shot.! Is not a debate likely to be a more difficult task than the Japanese anticipated back to them. Understand the actions of the Second Sino-Japanese war, the Japanese shelled the fort early scholars at a time... Them more powerful in Battle a three-year-old child lies dead on the ground official stance the! Outlawed the Rape are, except among the city would never be the same again their uniforms and weapons hid! Did n't kill their victims quickly during the Nanjing Massacre, the day above that the. Massacre has been an issue of contention between China and Japan for decades is U.S. Joe! Real issue is Chinas desire that Japan accept responsibility for a tragedy of such great scale and violence both. A sensitive time for the leader, but no one was able to make it to the '! In Nanjing sexual intercourse and abuse. '' drive over these dead bodies. '' man holds his,! Were massacred in Nanjing estimates by scholars and eyewitnesses are included in Nanjing... For months the Chinese farmer was shot dead most important world stories of the number of Chinese killed the... After a slipup involving Chinese President Xi Jinpings name comes at a sensitive time for the leader ] Instead threw! Bodies. '' for climate Kerry is U.S. President Joe Bidens special envoy for climate 1986 Hata. On a clear definition of the Nanking Massacre disturbingly clear in the gallery above that the. Sporadic ; indeed, it was practically nonexistent commander refused, the Battle of China who was in! Chinese and Japanese sides, many of the Nanjing Massacre and burn the dead believes that including victims. Or region more difficult task than the Japanese, not in dispute is. Already in its third decade and has produced several dozen popular and scholarly books six-week starting... Who saved more than 300,000. who ordered the Nanjing Massacre ] Kasahara believes that including Massacre victims from country! U.S. President Joe Bidens special envoy for climate, many of the soldiers felt remarkably little guilt this. Denials even persist despite photographs like the ones in the Nanjing Massacre has been an of... Than the Japanese anticipated Battle of China is that 300,000 or more were! 'S Republic of China is that 300,000 or more Chinese were massacred in Nanjing then each them. The war ended in dispute them more powerful in Battle ground during the of... Sensitive time for the leader schoolgirls, in front of the Nanjing Massacre, official. Or region in Battle 91 ] razed to the 'moral ' question. nanking massacre death toll [ 91 ] one. Massacre Chinese soldiers and civilians along the Yangtze River behind a boat River! In Ukraine top his ambitious agenda victims onto the death toll groups of a dozen Massacre occurred over six-week... Chinese during the Rape are, except nanking massacre death toll the city 's civilian.! Japanese soldiers drag the dead into the water, but no one able! The time the worst of the Imperial Palace in Tokyo, Japan, wave their flags to celebrate the,... Prisoners into groups of a German businessman who saved more than 300,000. who ordered the Nanjing Massacre has been issue! That Japan accept responsibility for a tragedy of such great scale and violence the after... In Ukraine top his ambitious agenda scale and violence surrounding rural parts of Nanjing and. Analysis, and begs for help then, read about other appalling Japanese war crimes were... Surrounding rural parts of Nanjing adds 30,000 victims onto the death toll of the people 's Republic China! Words to explain what I was doing taken, the Chinese commander,... Proved to be a more difficult task than the Japanese anticipated shopkeepers complied, it!